Pocket watch appraisal

Communicate directly with a qualified specialist and get a fair market valuation of your item, typically in 48 hours or less.
Submit your item

Mearto Specialist:

Jonty C.

Jonty has been working in the jewellery field for more than 40 years, 15 of which he spent in senior positions at Sotheby’s. In 1999, he fulfilled a long-held dream and started his own private consulting business in London. Jonty is a qualified gemmologist and diamond expert and an appraiser for jewellery and watches. He is a diamond broker and gemologist, and is a Registered Expert Witness (Civil) in the United Kingdom.

Valuing Your Antique Pocket Watch

There are several factors to consider when you need to put a value on an antique pocket watch. We will cover the most important ones here.

What brand is it?

When you are trying to collect or sell antique pocket watches, the brand of the watch is a highly important factor. The brand is usually the first thing that potential buyers want to know about the watch when you put it up for sale. Each period has prominent brands and makers that introduced unique designs to the industry. Therefore, these notable brands are highly sought after by serious collectors.

Below is a glimpse of some of the top brands that manufactured antique pocket watches:

  • Bregeut
  • Patek Philippe
  • Girard-Perregaux
  • Tissot
  • Audemars Piguet
  • Vacheron Constantin

We do a lot of pocket watch appraisals - here are a few examples from our customers:

made by the Illinois Watch company, Springfield Illinois, made circa 1931. $750 to $850

Elgin - A 14k Gold Open Faced Pocket Watch, circa 1915. $800 to $1000

How old is the pocket watch?

The age of a pocket watch is also a significant factor in valuing this antique item. To determine how old the pocket watch is, you must look at the serial number on the movement. It is important to note that the serial number on the movement and the watch case are different. Hence, you should not commit the mistake of looking at the serial number of the watch case (especially since the movement and cases are manufactured separately and often by different companies).

If you bought your pocket watch from Switzerland or some parts of Europe, it might be more difficult to determine the age of your pocket watch. Most of the watch manufacturers in this region did not brand their watches with serial numbers.

The style of the watch is assessed in order to determine how old the watch is. However, only expert watch professionals are able to accurately determine the age of a watch. Make sure you have it looked into by someone who is a certified professional.

It is important to note that while old watches are valuable, they are not considered automatically rare. There were some manufacturers from the old era that produced millions of pocket watches. This means that there are plenty of these watches in the market and this will cause the value of your watch to decrease significantly. Old and rare pocket watches are the ones that are expected to get a higher appraisal.

What is the provenance?

The provenance of antique pocket watches is at the forefront of trying to determine its market value. Aside from being old or having a notable name brand, its provenance can give it more value. In fact, many expert appraisers claim that provenance is far more important than the condition and age of the watch. To be specific, what appraisers are looking for is to determine the previous owner of a particular watch. If it is linked to any notable figure, then you can expect that your antique pocket watch will get a boost in market value.

To verify the authenticity of the provenance, it is best if you can provide the “cosigned by original owner” seal. Even if the watch might not be in top condition (such as having a few scratches), it can still be considered valuable especially if it has been owned by someone popular or a well-known figure.

Provenance is important, but without proper documentation it can be hard to convince an auction house or a buyer that your provenance is what you say it is.

How is the quality of your watch?

The quality of the pocket watch is an obvious factor when appraising it. There was a time in history when the manufacturers of pocket watches were so fixated on developing an efficient “dollar watch”. This resulted in the manufacture of several low quality watches as they were targeted to be sold at a low price.

If you want to determine the quality of a pocket watch, look at how it was finished. The high quality finishes are polished, comes with gold jewel settings, or made with damaskeened plates. If the watch you have, comes with a simple finish with rarely any polish at all, it might not be worth much. The jewel count, on top of the finish, is also a significant factor in determining the value of a pocket watch. The higher the number of jewels used for making it, the higher the quality, too. It is easy to determine the jewel count of a pocket watch. It is indicated by the number followed by letter J on your pocket watch.

A watch that has been unaltered since it was released from the factory will have more value than those that have been altered. Some watches might have been re-cased or have their parts replaced. If your watch has not met these conditions, then you can get maximum appraisal for your watch.

What materials are used?

The type of materials used for making the pocket watch is an essential factor in determining its value. It is what is inside that truly counts and only expert appraisers are able to determine the value of your pocket watch based on these materials. A pocket watch that is made with solid gold is obviously more valuable than ones that are gold plated. Moreover, there are some that do not even contain gold but rather encased in nickel. It is also important to examine the materials used for the train wheels and jewel casings as these too can heavily influence its cost upon appraisal.

How to Spot a Fake Watch

Being able to differentiate a fake pocket watch from an authentic one is highly important. And yet, it is also quite difficult to do. The cost of authentic and rare antique pocket watches can be quite expensive. If you are going to buy them online, you need to keep a close eye on the specific details mentioned above – finish, jewel settings, serial number, manufacturer’s seal, and watch case. Therefore, it is important to be able to examine as many photos of the item as possible so you can verify its authenticity. Or, you can look for websites that sell antique pocket watches that have been verified by expert appraisers. This will guarantee that any pocket watch sold on the website had been verified for its authenticity.

At Mearto, you can expect that any item you find had been looked into by expert and professional appraisers. This will give you confidence that what you see is what you get. There is no need to spend thousands of dollars on counterfeit items.

What our customers say:

150,000+ satisfied customers

4.6/5 ★★★★★ rating

I received a response and information regarding my items in less than 48 hours, which I appreciated. The appraiser was very knowledgable.

Kristal Hicks Torpey

I highly recommend Mearto if you're curious of the value or background of any item in your home.
The appraisal I received from Mearto was detailed and thorough.

Austin Phillips

I received a quality appraisal in less than 48 hours. I also acquired a second opinion of an industry expert who concurred with Mearto's appraised value.  

Todd Roper

Prices that scale with the size of your collection:

1   Appraisal
Buy now
3   Appraisals
Buy now
5   Appraisals
Buy now
10   Appraisals
Buy now